Striving towards unity, spontaneity and simplicity of form (as articulated by Bernard Leach in his 1940s classic, A Potter's Book)

 

 

 Shopping

 Instructions
 

 

 Other  Resources 

 Portfolio
 Statement
 Home

 

 Artist's Statement (Fall, 2006)


I began studying ceramics out of curiosity, especially about the magic by which a humble lump of clay on a potter’s wheel can be transformed into an elegant vessel with a few quick gestures.  My teachers quickly informed me, however, that they were art teachers and they don’t encourage mere curiosity about technique.

So I started trying to come to terms with the artistic aspect of ceramics by reading Zen and the Art of Pottery [1] by Kenneth R. Beittel.  He included a list of “Great Pots I Have Known,” and the first one was a paddled Tenmoku vase made by Bernard Leach.  That pot had a laid-down lip and subtle decorations against a mostly black background.  It did not seem that great to me, but I was curious enough to read Leach’s famous work, A Potters Book [2], next.  In the first chapter, Leach defined what he called the Sung standard as

“a striving towards unity, spontaneity and simplicity of form."

Nowadays it is customary to dismiss Leach.  I even heard Edmond de Waal characterize Leach’s idea of the Sung standard as a “miasma.” On the other hand, Garth Clark admitted it is “still a benchmark” in the second of his essays on The Future of Functional Pottery in his 2003 book Shards [3]. I personally can agree that Leach went too far in his later book The Unknown Craftsman [4], but I think A Potter’s Book still stands on its own merits. 

Next, I read Pottery Form [5] by Daniel Rhodes and appreciated his sly hints that good form often relates to the human form.  About that time, I was also advised to look at Picasso’s work in ceramics.  I had already noticed a clever piece in one of Susan Peterson’s The Craft and Art of Clay [6].  I also found a picture on the studio wall at the college that seemed to illustrate both Leach’s idea that

"... a pot starts by being an abstract shape, and consequently any pattern applied to its surface calls for formal emphasis in order to attain unity with it."

and  Rhodes’ suggestion that allusion to the human form works best for pottery.  Many other interesting pieces can be seen in the catalog of Picasso Painter and Sculptor in Clay [7], which opened at the Royal Academy of Arts, London in 1998 and moved to the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York in 1999.

In the fall of 2004, I attended a Symposium at Harvard that included a demo by Bizen potter Ryuichi Kakurezaki.  Jeff Shapiro, who translated for him, likes to say Kakurezaki enjoys rock-star popularity in Japan.  Although Kakurezaki has a design background, he claims he doesn’t think about design and has said

“Concept is 100%."

instead.  I think this means that his forms are not completely abstract to begin with, which should improve the odds of finding a unifying surface treatment.

Harvard held another workshop focused on Bizen pottery in the spring of 2006.   This time Kakurezaki’s teacher, Living National Treasure Jun Isezaki, also participated along with Tim Rowan, who studied under Kakurezaki , and Jun’s son Koichiro, who studied for 2 years with Shapiro. Shapiro again served as translator for the demos. 

Isezaki seems like a very straightforward person.  He was once asked [8] why he makes certain shapes exactly the same as they were made centuries ago.  His reply was simply

“What works well need not be changed."

I think that should be the case if the best forms refer to the human form, which hasn’t changed at all on that time scale.

References

  1. Kenneth R. Beittell, Zen and the Art of Pottery, Weatherhill, New York (1989).
  2. Bernard Leach, A Potter’s Book, Second Edition, Faber and Faber, London 1945.
  3. Garth Clark, Shards, Ceramic Arts Foundation (2003).
  4. Soetsu Yanaki (Adapted by Bernard Leach), The Unknown Craftsman – A Japanese Insight into Beauty, Kodansha America, New York [1972].
  5. Daniel Rhodes, Pottery Form, Pitman Publishing, London (1976).
  6. Susan Peterson, The Craft and Art of Clay, Third Edition, Prentice Hall (2000).
  7. Picasso Painter and Sculptor in Clay, Marilyn McCully, Ed., Harry N. Abrahams, New York (1998).
  8. Robert Yellin, “TRADITION AND INNOVATION Lightning strikes in Isezaki's Bizen,” Japan Times, June 13, 2001 (online at http://www.e-yakimono.net/html/isezaki-jun-jt.html ).

 

(last updated September 10, 2006)

 

 Copyright 2006

 Terence J. Nelson